King Lear Critics

Andrew Green on truth the audience is continually forced to recognise the gap which lies between utterance and truth
Giles Block on words in plays it is usually the one who has the best words who comes out on top
Giles Block on rhyme the language of spells
Charles Lamb Lear is essentially impossible to be represented on a stage
Dr Samuel Johnson contrary to the natural ideas of justice
Coleridge like the hurricane and the whirlpool
Susan Bruce on Bastards Bastards are evil in Renaissance drama because . . . they have a clear motive to contest the hegemonic ideology
Terry Eagleton on the Fool the Fool is wiser than fools because he knows his own folly and so can see through theirs
Terry Eagleton on Cordelia spokeswoman for the material bonds of kinship
Terry Eagleton on Language Language, like much else in the play, has a problem in pitching itself at an elusive point between too much and too little
Terry Eagleton on Edmund He is a self-creating opportunist who can manipulate others’ appetites to his own advantage precisely because he knows his own so well
Aristotle Hamartia, Peripeteia, Anagnorisis
Terence Hawkes on Love from the first moments of the play, a wholly debased kind of ‘loving’ can be seen to operate
Terence Hawkes on Edmund he is the product of lust, not love . . . inevitably, he will be tainted by such a background
Nietzsche the self-oblivion of the Dionysiac – Apollonian
Kathleen McLuskie on Feminism Feminism cannot simply take ‘the woman’s part’ when that part has been so morally loaded and theatrically circumscribed
Arnold Kettle on Edmund Edmund has none of his father’s amiable, conservative illusions. He is intelligent, active and ruthless
Arnold Kettle on Edmund Summary man with the lid off
Arnold Kettle on the storm the storm in Lear ‘works’ artistically on a number of levels
Arnold Kettle on G and R they are at once shrewd, able, shallow and morally impervious, and they are rivals because they are alike
Arnold Kettle on Lear’s Madness Lear’s madness is not so much a breakdown as a breakthrough. It is necessary
Arnold Kettle on Cordelia she seems to express in her very person the ‘better way’ to which Lear has come through
Karl Marx force is the midwife of every old society which is pregnant with a new one
Gwynne Blakemore Evans on Lear appears in the opening scene as justice itself
Kenneth Muir on Lear loses the world and gains his soul
Kiernan Ryan on the Storm the scene enforces the arresting realisation that distinctions of rank have no natural or intrinsic authority at all
Coppelia Kahn on Power Lear’s very insistence on paternal power, in fact, belies its shakiness
Coppelia Kahn on Repression In this patriarchal world, masculine identity depends on repressing the vulnerability
Coppelia Kahn on Shakespeare I find family relationships and gender identity central to Shakespeare’s imagination
Lawrence Stone on Sixteenth-Century Families – 3 Ps This sixteenth-century aristocratic family was patrilinear, primogenitural and patriarchal
James I Kings are compared to fathers in families
Coppelia Kahn on Control and Dependence He wants two mutually exclusive things at once: to have absolute control over those closest to him and to be absolutely dependent on them
Freud his majesty, the baby
Coppelia Kahn on Generational Conflict generational conflicts entwine with and intensify gender conflicts
Coppelia Kahn on Goneril stealthy and lustful
Kiernan Ryan on Catharthis Shakespeare’s tragic vision affords no therapeutic catharsis
Kiernan Ryan on Alternative Potentiality Shakespearean tragedy is defined by its organising awareness of alternative potentiality
Aristotle on Justice Distributive and Retributive
Kiernan Ryan on Generational Conflicts parallel generational conflicts which rip the families of Lear and Gloucester apart
Kiernan Ryan on the Fool the Fool sardonically shuffles together bitter actualities
Graham Martins on King Lear a pattern of carefully juxtaposed fragments
Graham Martins on Edmund self-confident villainy of Edmund
Graham Martins on Edgar he is the living symbol of the compassionate understanding that Lear begins to achieve
Graham Martins on Gloucester’s Sight Gloucester, his eyes still intact, sees and does not recognise, hears and does not understand
Graham Martins on Gloucester Gloucester is the devil
Graham Martins on Poor Tom close to the state of the beast
Graham Martins on Edgar and Gloucester the son has become his father’s father
Graham Martins on Albany a ‘bitty’ part that never quite firms up
Graham Martins on Speech speech is virtually the plays soul dimension
A. C. Bradley psychological flaw
Jennifer Wallace on Aristotle nearly all writing on tragedy returns to Aristotle
Hegel tragedy dramatises the moment of collision between two equally justified powers